A metal roadside mailbox on a wooden post in front of a white single-story house with a covered porch, photographed at sunset.

Do I Call My Insurance or Theirs After an Accident

Call your own insurer first, no matter who caused the accident, then let the claims process sort out who pays.

Compare my rates

Free to compare

Call your own insurer, not theirs

Report the accident to your own insurance company first. Your policy likely requires you to report any accident within a certain time, and that duty exists whether or not you were at fault. Calling your own insurer keeps you protected under your own coverage no matter how the fault gets decided later.

You can also give a statement to the other driver's insurer, but you don't have to do it first and you don't have to do it alone. Your own agent or claims adjuster can walk you through what to say and can also deal with the other insurer on your behalf.

A gray plastic bin full of mail and envelopes sits on a black bench on a porch of a stone-faced house, with a potted shrub, a walkway, and a silver car in the driveway blurred in the background.

Who was at fault changes what happens next, not who you call

Fault decides who ends up paying, not which company you contact first. Even if the other driver clearly caused the accident, your insurer still needs to know. They may open what's called a claim against the other driver's insurer, and having your own insurer involved from the start protects you if that process stalls or if fault is disputed.

If you wait and only talk to the other driver's insurer, you lose the person whose job is to represent your side. Adjusters from the other company work for that company, not for you.

If the other driver is uninsured or underinsured, this matters even more. Your own policy may have coverage for exactly that situation, but only if you've reported the accident to your insurer.

Ask your own insurer directly how fault gets determined in your state, since some states weigh it differently than others.

An open white mailbox holding envelopes sits on a weathered wooden bench on a porch with siding and a column, with a blurred silver pickup truck parked by a street beyond a lawn.

What matters most is reporting it, not which company hears it first

The bigger mistake isn't calling the wrong company first, it's not calling at all. Drivers sometimes skip reporting a minor accident because they don't want their premium to go up, or because the other driver asked them to handle it privately. That can leave you without coverage if the damage turns out to be worse than it looked, or if the other driver changes their story later.

Write down what happened while it's fresh. The other driver's name, insurance company, policy number, and license plate. Photos of both cars and the scene if you can take them safely.

Tell your insurer what you saw and what you know. Don't guess about fault or apologize in a way that sounds like an admission, since that statement can follow the claim.

If you're not sure whether an accident is worth reporting, ask your agent before deciding not to call. That conversation doesn't commit you to filing a claim.

Questions people ask about this

Will my insurance rate go up if I report an accident that wasn't my fault?

Not automatically, since many insurers only raise rates for accidents where you were found at fault. Ask your insurer directly how they handle not-at-fault accidents, because the answer varies by company and sometimes by state.

What if the other driver asks to settle without involving insurance?

You're not required to agree, and it's usually safer not to. Without a claim on record, you have no protection if repair costs turn out higher than expected or the other driver backs out of the agreement.

Do I have to give a recorded statement to the other driver's insurance company?

You can decline or ask to have your own insurer or an attorney present first. The other company's adjuster represents their interests, not yours, so it's worth understanding your rights before speaking with them.

What happens if I don't report the accident to my insurer at all?

You could lose coverage for that accident if your insurer later finds out, since most policies require prompt reporting. Check your policy for the exact reporting window so you know your obligation.

Who pays for my car if the other driver is uninsured?

That depends on whether you have uninsured motorist coverage on your own policy. If you do, your insurer handles the claim directly, which is one more reason to report the accident to them first.

See how a clean accident record and the right coverage affect what you'd pay now.

A single-storey house with horizontal lap siding and a gabled roof beside a wide concrete driveway, with a silver sedan parked under an attached carport during heavy rain.

Call your insurer this week, even if the damage looks minor or the other driver seems at fault. Have the other driver's name, insurance company, and policy number ready, along with photos of the vehicles if you took any. Ask your insurer how they handle fault determination and whether reporting this accident is likely to affect your rate. If the other driver is uninsured, ask specifically what coverage you have for that situation. Keep a copy of whatever claim number or reference you're given, and avoid giving a recorded statement to the other insurer until you've talked to your own agent.

More articles