A black mailbox with a red flag mounted on a wooden post, with a suburban house and large tree illuminated by a sunset in the background.

How to File a Car Insurance Claim Against Someone

You file the claim with the other driver's insurer, not your own, and you'll need their information and your own account of what happened.

Compare my rates

Free to compare

File with the other driver's insurance company

When another driver is at fault, you file what's called a third party claim directly with their insurance company. You'll need their name, their insurer, and their policy number, which you should get at the scene or from the police report. Most insurers let you start this by phone or online once you have that information.

The other insurer will investigate before they pay anything. They'll want your account of the accident, any photos you took, and the police report if one was filed. This can take longer than a claim with your own insurer, because the other company owes you nothing until they decide their driver was at fault.

A clipboard with blank white paper and a silver ballpoint pen rests on a dark table in front of a glass wall, behind which a gray car is parked.

Whether fault is clear changes how this goes

If the police report names the other driver at fault, or if there were witnesses, the claim usually moves faster. The insurer still reviews it, but there's less for them to dispute.

If fault is unclear or contested, the other insurer may delay or deny the claim while they investigate. This is common after accidents with no witnesses, conflicting accounts, or an officer who didn't assign fault.

In either case, write down what happened while it's fresh and keep anything that supports your version: photos, the report number, names of anyone who saw it happen. You can't control how the other insurer rules, but you can control what you hand them.

If the claim stalls or gets denied and you believe the other driver was at fault, you can also file with your own insurer under your collision coverage, if you have it, and let your insurer pursue the other company directly.

A man in a dark jacket and light trousers walks away along a leaf-covered sidewalk beside a gray sedan parked on a tree-lined street with yellow autumn foliage.

What your own insurer's role is, even if you're not at fault

Call your own insurer even if you plan to file against the other driver. This isn't the same as filing a claim against your own policy, and in most states it won't affect your premium just for reporting an accident you didn't cause.

Your insurer can confirm what your policy covers if the other driver's insurer delays or denies the claim. Many policies include coverage for exactly this situation, often called uninsured or underinsured motorist coverage, which applies if the other driver has no insurance or not enough to cover the damage.

Your insurer can also tell you how a claim against another driver interacts with your own coverage, since this varies by state and by policy. That's a question for them, not a guess you should make on your own.

Questions people ask about this

What information do I need from the other driver after an accident?

You need their name, insurance company, and policy number at minimum. Their license plate and driver's license number help too, since the insurer may ask for them to confirm the policy. If a police officer responds, this information is usually recorded in the report, which you can request a copy of.

How long does a claim against another driver's insurance take?

It depends on how clear fault is and how busy the insurer's claims process is. A claim with clear fault and good documentation moves faster than one where the insurer has to investigate who caused the accident. Ask the adjuster handling your claim for an estimated timeline once it's opened.

What if the other driver's insurance denies my claim?

You can ask the insurer for their reason in writing, which most states require them to provide. If you disagree, you can file with your own insurer under your uninsured or underinsured motorist coverage, if you have it, or contact your state's insurance department about how to dispute the denial.

Can I still file if there was no police report?

Yes, but it may be harder to establish fault without one. Insurers rely on police reports, photos, and witness statements to decide who was at fault, so without a report you'll want other documentation, like photos of the scene and contact information for any witnesses.

Will filing a claim against another driver raise my own insurance rate?

In most states, an accident that wasn't your fault shouldn't raise your premium, but this depends on your state and your insurer's own rules. Ask your insurer directly how they handle not-at-fault accidents before you assume either way.

If you're dealing with a claim that's dragging on or a rate that went up anyway, it's worth seeing what other insurers would charge you.

A person's arm in a plaid shirt pulls a dipstick from a car engine under a raised hood, with a low retail building and parking lot in the background.

Get the other driver's name, insurance company, and policy number if you don't have them yet, along with a copy of the police report. Call your own insurer this week, even if you're not filing against your policy, so they have the accident on record and can tell you what your own coverage offers if the other claim stalls. Write down your account of the accident now, while the details are clear, and keep any photos or witness names together in one place. If the other insurer asks for a recorded statement, ask your own insurer or an attorney what that involves before you give one.

More articles