
Will Used Parts Be Used in My Repair
It depends on the kind of coverage you have and what your state allows, not on your age or driving history.
Free to compare
It depends on your policy, not on you
Whether used or aftermarket parts show up in your repair comes down to the type of claim and what your policy says about repair parts. Insurers that cover collision repairs often reserve the right to specify used, reconditioned, or aftermarket parts instead of new ones from the manufacturer, especially on an older car.
Your age doesn't factor into this at all. What matters is your policy's language, the age and value of your car, and in some states, rules about what the shop has to disclose to you before the work starts.

Your car's age and value drive the decision
Insurers generally make this call based on how much your car is worth and how old it is. A newer car is more likely to get original manufacturer parts. An older car is more likely to get used or aftermarket parts, because the insurer is paying to restore it to its condition before the damage, not to upgrade it.
If you want original parts and your policy allows you to ask for them, you may have to pay the difference in cost yourself. Check your policy's language on repair parts, or ask your insurer directly before a claim happens, not during one.
Some policies include an endorsement that guarantees original manufacturer parts regardless of the car's age. If having that matters to you, it's worth asking whether your policy includes it or can be added.

Your state may require the shop to tell you
A number of states require body shops to disclose in writing when they plan to use used, reconditioned, or aftermarket parts in a repair, and some give you the right to refuse certain parts. This rule varies by state, so check with your state's insurance department or attorney general's office for what applies where you live.
Even where disclosure is required, the shop and insurer still decide what parts to use within those rules. Your job as the car owner is usually to ask for the disclosure in writing and read it before you sign off on the repair.
If a shop installs a part you didn't agree to or weren't told about, that's a separate problem from the insurer's parts policy, and it's worth raising with your state's consumer protection office.
Questions people ask about this
Can I refuse aftermarket parts on my repair?
In some states you can, depending on what your policy says and what your state's disclosure laws require. Ask the shop for the parts disclosure in writing before the repair starts, and ask your insurer whether refusing means you'll owe the cost difference yourself.
Are used parts as safe as new ones?
A reputable shop will only install used parts that have been inspected and are structurally sound for the repair. Ask the shop directly what inspection the part went through, since standards can differ between shops and part suppliers.
Will my warranty be affected if used parts are installed?
It depends on your car's manufacturer warranty terms and the type of part used. Check your owner's warranty booklet or call the manufacturer to ask whether non-original parts affect coverage on the repaired area.
Does my insurer have to tell me which parts they'll use?
This depends on your state's laws and your policy's terms, not on a universal rule. Ask your insurer directly, before the repair is authorized, what kind of parts they plan to use and get the answer in writing if you can.
Can I pay extra to get original manufacturer parts instead?
Many insurers will let you pay the difference between an aftermarket part and an original one, though this isn't guaranteed everywhere. Ask your insurer or the repair shop what the price difference would be before agreeing to the repair plan.
If knowing your parts coverage matters to you, see what other policies offer before your next renewal.

Before your car ever needs a repair, pull out your policy and look for the section on repair parts or replacement parts. Call your insurer and ask plainly whether they use used or aftermarket parts on claims like yours, and whether you can add or already have an endorsement for original manufacturer parts. If you're ever in a claim, ask the shop for a written disclosure of the parts they plan to use before you authorize the work. Keep that disclosure with your claim paperwork in case a question comes up later.


