
Does a Claim Follow Me to a New Insurer
A claim doesn't move with you from one insurer to the next, but the record of it does, and a new insurer will ask about it.
Free to compare
The claim stays with the old insurer, the history doesn't disappear
When you switch insurers, your new company doesn't inherit your old policy or the claim itself. What follows you is your claims history, which any insurer you apply to can pull and review before they quote you. So the claim isn't attached to you the way a mark on a license is, but it isn't hidden either.
For a driver who's been with one company a long time, this matters because a claim that didn't raise your rate much with your current insurer could still affect what a new insurer offers you. Each company weighs claims differently, and some weigh a long clean record before the claim more heavily than others. Whether it affects your quote at all depends on how recent the claim was and what kind it was.

What kind of claim it was
Insurers generally distinguish between claims where you were at fault and claims where you weren't, and between claims for things like a windshield or a weather event versus a claim after a collision. A not-at-fault claim or a comprehensive claim tends to carry less weight than a claim where you caused the accident.
This is worth knowing because a driver with a single not-at-fault claim on their record sometimes assumes it will count against them the same way a fault accident would. It's reasonable to ask a new insurer directly how they treat that particular type of claim before you commit to a quote.
If you're not sure how your claim was coded, your current insurer can tell you. It's on your claims history report, and you're entitled to see it.

How long ago it happened
Insurers look back a set number of years when pricing a new policy, and a claim outside that window typically has little or no effect on your quote. The exact length of that look back period is set by the insurer and sometimes by the state, so it isn't the same everywhere.
If your claim happened a while back, it's worth asking a prospective insurer how far back they look before you assume it's still counted against you. Some companies look back further than others for the same type of claim.
If the claim is recent, expect it to come up. The new insurer will likely ask about it directly when you apply, and giving an accurate answer up front avoids problems later if they pull your claims history and find something you didn't mention.
Questions people ask about this
How far back can an insurer see my claims history?
It depends on the insurer and sometimes the state, since there's no single rule that applies everywhere. Insurers typically pull a report that covers several years of claims activity. If you want to know exactly how far back a company you're considering looks, ask them directly.
Does a claim affect my rate even if I switch insurers?
It can, because a new insurer reviews your claims history as part of deciding what to charge you. Whether it actually changes your rate depends on the type of claim, how long ago it happened, and how that particular insurer weighs it.
What's the difference between a claim and an accident on my record?
A claim is a request for payment you filed with an insurer, while an accident may or may not have involved a claim. If you paid for repairs yourself without filing anything, there may be no claim on your history even though the accident happened.
Can I ask an insurer to ignore an old claim?
You can ask, but whether they will depends entirely on their own rules, not on anything you can require. Some insurers have review periods or exceptions for a single old claim. The only way to know is to ask the specific company you're getting a quote from.
Will a claim show up if I add a new car to my policy instead of switching?
Adding a car to an existing policy with the same insurer doesn't trigger a new pull of your claims history the way applying with a new insurer does. Your current insurer already has your claim on file and has likely already priced it into your policy.
See how different insurers price your record before you decide to switch.

Ask your current insurer for a copy of your claims history report so you know exactly how your claim is coded and dated. When you request quotes from other insurers, mention the claim up front rather than waiting for them to find it. Ask each one directly how far back they look and how they treat that type of claim. If one quote comes back much higher than the others, ask that insurer specifically what drove the difference. Comparing a few quotes side by side will tell you more about how this particular claim is being weighed than guessing on your own.


