A black mailbox on a wooden post in front of a ranch-style house at sunset.

Will My Insurance Go Up if I Make a Claim

A claim can raise your rate, but it depends on who was at fault and how your insurer treats your history.

Compare my rates

Free to compare

Usually, but not always

If you file a claim and you were at fault, your rate is likely to go up at your next renewal. Insurers price your policy on the risk you present, and a claim where you caused the damage tells them that risk was realized.

If the other driver was at fault and their insurer pays, or if the claim was for something outside your control like a weather event or a parked car being hit, your own rate often stays the same. Some insurers also forgive a first claim entirely. The exact outcome depends on your insurer's accident forgiveness rules and how your state allows insurers to use claims history, so the honest answer is to ask your agent how this specific claim will be treated before you decide whether to file.

View from inside a car of a person's arm in a knit sweater resting on the open passenger window frame, with a tree-lined residential street and houses outside.

Who was at fault changes everything

A claim where you're found at fault is treated differently than one where you aren't. When you cause an accident, the insurer pays out and then prices your next renewal to reflect that you were involved in a loss they had to cover.

When another driver is at fault and their insurer pays the claim, it typically doesn't count against you the same way, because the loss wasn't caused by your driving. Some states and insurers still note that you were involved in an incident, even if you weren't at fault, so it's worth asking your insurer directly whether a not-at-fault claim shows up on your record at all.

Comprehensive claims, like a cracked windshield, storm damage, or a stolen car, are usually treated more gently than at-fault collision claims, since they don't say anything about how you drive. Ask your agent how your specific insurer treats comprehensive claims before assuming the worst.

A person in a plaid shirt and jeans holds a dipstick over an open car hood in a parking lot, with a gray sedan, a white pickup truck and a storefront in the background.

What your insurer and your record allow

Every insurer sets its own rules for how claims affect your rate, and those rules can differ quite a bit from one company to the next. Some offer accident forgiveness after a long stretch without a claim, meaning your first at-fault claim in years doesn't move your rate at all. Others apply it automatically, and some require you to ask for it or pay extra for it.

Your claims history over the recent past also matters more than any single claim. One claim after a long clean record is treated differently than a second or third claim in a short span, because the second claim tells the insurer the first wasn't an isolated event.

The size of the claim matters too. A small claim, especially one close to what you'd pay out of pocket anyway, may not be worth filing once you weigh the cost of a higher premium against the payout. Call your insurer and ask what a specific claim amount would likely do to your renewal before you file, so you're deciding with real information instead of a guess.

Questions people ask about this

Should I pay out of pocket instead of filing a claim?

It depends on how much the repair costs compared to what a rate increase would cost you over time. If the damage is minor, paying it yourself can work out cheaper than filing, since a claim can affect your premium for several renewal cycles. Ask your insurer what a claim of that size would likely do to your rate before you decide.

How long does a claim stay on my record?

This varies by insurer and by state, since each sets its own rules for how long a claim affects pricing. Some insurers look back a few years, others look further. Ask your insurer directly how long a claim stays part of their pricing decision for you.

Does accident forgiveness mean my rate never goes up?

No, it means a specific claim, usually your first in a long time, won't be used to raise your rate. It doesn't cover every claim going forward, and not every insurer offers it automatically. Ask your agent whether you already have it or whether it's something you'd need to add.

Will switching insurers after a claim help or hurt me?

A new insurer will usually ask about your claims history and price your policy based on it, so switching doesn't erase the claim. In some cases a new insurer may quote you higher because of it, in others the difference may be small. Getting a few quotes lets you see how different insurers actually weigh your record.

Does a claim affect my rate if I wasn't driving the car?

This depends on who was covered under the policy and what your insurer's rules say about other listed drivers. If someone else on your policy was at fault while driving your car, it can still affect your rate, since the policy itself is what paid out. Ask your insurer how they treat claims involving other drivers on your policy.

See how your rate compares before deciding whether to file.

A person in a hooded gray raincoat walks across an asphalt parking lot past a long row of parked cars, with a light-colored industrial building and bare trees behind them under an overcast sky.

Before you file anything, call your insurer or agent and ask how this specific claim would affect your renewal, since they can look at your policy and your state's rules directly. Have your policy number and a rough repair estimate ready so they can give you a real answer rather than a general one. Ask specifically whether you have accident forgiveness and whether this claim would use it up. If the estimated cost is close to what you'd pay out of pocket, weigh that against the likely rate increase over the next few years, not just the next renewal. Once you know how your current insurer would handle it, get a couple of quotes from other insurers so you can see whether this claim would be priced differently elsewhere.

More articles