An older man and woman sit in the front seats of a dark blue car, viewed through the windshield.

Will Car Insurance Go Up if Not at Fault

A not-at-fault accident can still raise your premium, because insurers price on the fact that you were in a crash, not just who caused it.

Compare my rates

Free to compare

It depends on whether your insurer recovers its costs from the other driver

If your insurer gets its money back from the at-fault driver's insurance company, your rate usually stays where it was. If that recovery doesn't happen, or takes too long, or the other driver had no insurance, your insurer has paid out a claim with no reimbursement, and that can show up in your premium at renewal.

Some states have rules that limit or ban surcharges after an accident that's not your fault. Others leave it to the insurer. Your policy and your state's insurance department are the two places that actually answer this for your situation, not a general rule that applies everywhere.

Close-up of a black leather car seat back and headrest with metal posts, with a seat belt and buckle at the left and sunlight falling across the upholstery.

Whether the claim gets filed against your policy or theirs

When the other driver's insurer accepts fault quickly and pays for your damage, the claim runs through their policy, not yours. That's the cleanest outcome. Your own claims history shows nothing, and there's nothing for your insurer to react to at renewal.

When you file through your own insurer first and let them pursue the other side, the claim shows up on your record right away, even if your insurer later recovers every dollar. Some insurers remove it from your record once subrogation succeeds. Others leave the claim listed but don't count it against you for pricing. Ask your insurer directly which one they do.

If the other driver is uninsured or underinsured and you collect through your own uninsured motorist coverage, there's no other policy to recover from. That claim sits on your record as a paid loss, and whether it affects your premium depends on your insurer's rules and your state's.

If you're not sure which way your claim is being handled, call your insurer and ask. It's a fair question, and the answer changes what you should expect at your next renewal.

A silver sedan stops beside a stainless steel drive-through transaction unit set into a masonry block wall under a covered lane, with wet pavement and trees in the background.

What your state allows an insurer to do with a not-at-fault claim

A number of states restrict insurers from raising your rate because of an accident that was ruled someone else's fault. If you live in one of those states, a not-at-fault claim on your record should not move your premium, regardless of how the subrogation process goes.

In states without that protection, insurers can factor in any claim, at-fault or not, as part of their overall picture of your risk. Two or more claims in a short period, even if none were your fault, can read as a pattern to an insurer, even though each incident was out of your hands.

Your state's department of insurance can tell you exactly what the rule is where you live. That's a better source than asking around, because these rules vary and change, and your policy documents may reference your state's specific protections or lack of them.

Questions people ask about this

Does a not-at-fault accident show up on my driving record?

It can show up on your insurance claims history even when it doesn't appear on your motor vehicle record with the DMV. Those are two separate records. Insurers check the claims history when they price your renewal, so an accident can affect your premium even if it never touches your official driving record.

How long does a not-at-fault accident stay on my insurance history?

Insurers typically look back a set number of years when pricing a policy, and claims history reports usually cover a similar window. The exact length depends on your insurer and your state. Ask your current insurer how far back they look and whether a not-at-fault claim ages off the same way an at-fault one does.

Should I file a claim at all if the accident wasn't my fault?

If there's damage to your car or an injury, filing is usually the way to get it paid for, especially if the other driver's insurer is slow or disputes fault. Paying out of pocket to avoid a claim showing up isn't something most people can do for a serious repair. Ask your insurer how they handle not-at-fault claims before deciding, since some will reassure you up front that it won't be held against you.

Can I dispute a premium increase after a not-at-fault accident?

You can ask your insurer directly why your premium changed and whether the accident was a factor. If your state restricts surcharges for not-at-fault claims and you believe your insurer violated that, your state's department of insurance is the place to raise it. Keep any paperwork showing the accident was ruled the other driver's fault.

Will my insurance go up if the other driver was uninsured?

It can, because there's no other insurer to recover the payout from, and your insurer has still paid a claim. Whether it actually affects your premium depends on your insurer's rules and on whether your state limits surcharges in this situation. Ask your insurer how uninsured motorist claims are treated before you assume either way.

See what other insurers would charge you with a not-at-fault accident on your record.

A stainless steel drive-through banking window with a pneumatic tube unit set in a brick and stone wall, with a silver SUV parked under a canopy on the adjacent driveway.

Pull up your policy or call your insurer and ask two things: whether the claim is being filed against your policy or the other driver's, and whether a not-at-fault claim affects your premium under your state's rules. Write down what they tell you, since you may want to compare it against what you hear at renewal. If you're not satisfied with the answer, your state's department of insurance can confirm what the law actually requires where you live. Once you know how this accident is likely to be treated, get quotes from a few insurers before your renewal date arrives, so you have a real comparison in hand rather than just accepting the number your current insurer sends you.

More articles