
Does a Not at Fault Accident Raise Car Insurance
A crash that wasn't your fault shouldn't raise your rate, but it can still show up on your record and affect what you pay next.
Free to compare
In most cases, no, but it depends on your insurer
A not at fault accident usually does not raise your premium the way an at fault one does. Insurers price risk based on fault, and if the other driver's insurance pays the claim, your own driving record typically stays clean.
But some insurers look at the accident itself, not just who caused it, when they set your renewal rate. A claim on your policy, even a paid-out one, can factor into how a company views your risk going forward. Whether that happens depends on your insurer's rules and sometimes on your state.

Your insurer's accident forgiveness and rating rules
Some insurers promise never to raise your rate for a first not at fault accident, in writing, as part of the policy. Others make no such promise and may still factor the claim into your history.
If you're not sure what your policy says, call your agent and ask directly whether a not at fault accident affects your rate under their rules. Ask if they offer accident forgiveness and whether you already qualify for it.
If your current insurer does consider not at fault accidents when setting rates, that's worth knowing before your next renewal notice arrives. It's also a reason to compare what other insurers do with the same situation.

Whether you filed a claim at all
If you never filed a claim, because there was no damage worth reporting or you paid for repairs yourself, there's nothing on your record for an insurer to look at. The accident effectively didn't happen as far as pricing goes.
But if you did file a claim, even one the other driver's insurer paid in full, it can appear in your claims history. Insurers share claims data through industry databases, and a pattern of claims, regardless of fault, can sometimes influence how a company prices your policy.
This is different from a surcharge for being at fault. It's a broader read on how often you've been in accidents at all. Some insurers weigh this more than others, which is part of why it's worth asking directly rather than assuming.
Questions people ask about this
Will a not at fault accident show up on my driving record?
It may appear in your claims history even if it doesn't affect your license points. Claims history and driving record are tracked separately, and insurers can see both when they pull your file.
Can I remove a not at fault accident from my insurance history?
You generally can't erase a claim once it's filed, but you can ask your insurer to confirm in writing that it wasn't rated against you. If you believe the fault determination was wrong, ask your insurer how to dispute it.
Does accident forgiveness cover not at fault accidents too?
It depends on the insurer. Some forgiveness programs apply only to at fault accidents since those are the ones that typically raise rates, so ask your insurer specifically what their forgiveness policy covers.
Should I still report a not at fault accident to my insurer?
Most policies require you to report any accident regardless of fault, so check your policy terms before deciding not to. Failing to report one you were required to disclose can cause problems separate from the rate question.
Will my rate go up if the other driver was uninsured?
This depends on your state and your policy, since an uninsured driver changes who pays the claim. Ask your insurer how a claim paid under your own uninsured motorist coverage is treated when your policy renews.
If you're unsure how your current insurer handles this, it may be worth seeing what others would offer you instead.

Pull out your policy or call your agent this week and ask two things: whether your insurer rates not at fault accidents at all, and whether you have accident forgiveness already built in. Get the answer in writing or note who you spoke with and when. If the answer is unclear or unfavorable, use your renewal notice as the moment to compare what other insurers would charge for the same record. Have your claims history and the police report or claim number on hand when you do, since some insurers will ask for it.


