
Do Insurance Rates Go Up After No-Fault Accident
In many states your insurer can still raise your rate after a no-fault accident, because being blameless and being surcharged are two different questions.
Free to compare
Yes, a no-fault accident can still raise your rate
Being found not at fault doesn't automatically protect your premium. Insurers set their own rules for which accidents count against you, and in a lot of cases any claim paid out, regardless of fault, counts as a mark on your record.
This depends heavily on your state and your specific insurer. Some states require insurers to waive surcharges for accidents that weren't your fault. Others leave it up to the company. The only way to know for certain is to check your policy's accident forgiveness terms or ask your insurer directly how they classify the accident on their end.

What your insurer calls the accident matters more than what actually happened
Insurers track accidents in two ways: who was legally at fault, and who filed a claim. A no-fault accident still shows up as a claim on your record, and claims history is one of the biggest things insurers weigh when they set your renewal rate.
Some companies have a policy of not raising rates after an accident where their own investigation clears you of fault. Others treat any paid claim the same way, fault or no fault. You won't know which kind of company you have until you ask or read the fine print on accident forgiveness.
If you're a long-time customer, ask whether you already have accident forgiveness built into your policy. Many insurers offer it after a certain number of years with no claims, and it can mean a single no-fault accident does nothing to your premium at all.
If you don't have that protection, it's worth asking your agent now, before another accident happens, what their specific rule is for no-fault claims. That answer should be in writing somewhere, not just something an agent tells you over the phone.

Your state's no-fault law sets some of the rules, but not all of them
A number of states run no-fault insurance systems, where your own insurer pays your medical costs after an accident regardless of who caused it. That system was built to speed up claims, not to protect your rate. The two things aren't connected the way the name suggests.
Even in a no-fault state, your insurer can still look at the accident itself and decide it reflects on your risk as a driver. A few states have added separate protections that limit or ban surcharges for accidents that aren't your fault, but those protections vary and aren't universal.
The clearest way to find out what applies to you is to check with your state's department of insurance or ask your agent directly whether your state restricts no-fault surcharges. Don't assume the no-fault label alone keeps your rate where it is.
Questions people ask about this
How long does an accident stay on my insurance record?
This varies by insurer and by state, but accidents typically affect your rate for a period of years before dropping off. Ask your insurer directly how long they factor in a given accident when setting your renewal rate.
Can I dispute a surcharge after a no-fault accident?
You can ask your insurer to review how they classified the accident, especially if you have documentation showing you weren't at fault. Whether they'll reverse a surcharge depends entirely on their internal policy, so get their answer in writing.
Does accident forgiveness cover every type of accident?
Not necessarily. Accident forgiveness programs often have their own rules about which accidents qualify, and some exclude certain situations entirely. Read the terms of your specific policy or ask your agent what it actually covers.
Will my rate go up if the other driver was uninsured?
This depends on your state and your policy's uninsured motorist coverage. Some insurers treat these claims differently from other at-fault claims, so ask your insurer how they handle a claim against your own uninsured motorist coverage.
Should I report a minor no-fault accident to my insurer at all?
If you plan to file any claim, including one against the other driver's insurance, you generally need to report it to your own insurer too. Ask your agent how reporting an accident without filing a claim affects your record, since insurers vary on this.
If your rate is about to be affected by an accident, it helps to see what other insurers would charge you right now.

Pull out your policy or call your insurer this week and ask them directly how they classify the accident, as a chargeable incident or not. Ask whether you have accident forgiveness and what it actually covers. If you're not sure how your state treats no-fault surcharges, your state's department of insurance website will have that answer. Once you know how your current insurer is treating the accident, compare what a new policy would cost you elsewhere, since a different insurer's rules might work in your favor even if your current one doesn't budge.


