A wet dark gray four-door sedan sits in an empty parking lot on a rainy day, surrounded by green trees and shrubs.

Does Hitting a Deer Raise Car Insurance

Hitting a deer is almost always filed as a comprehensive claim, and comprehensive claims don't carry the same fault that raises your rate the way an at-fault accident does.

Compare my rates

Free to compare

Yes, it can, but not for the reason most people expect

Hitting a deer is usually covered under comprehensive insurance, the part of your policy that handles damage from things other than a collision with another car. Because you weren't at fault, insurers don't treat it the way they treat an at-fault accident. That alone keeps many drivers' rates from jumping.

But comprehensive claims still show up in your claims history, and some insurers raise rates after any claim, regardless of fault, especially if you've filed another one recently. Whether yours does depends on your insurer's own rules and sometimes your state. The only way to know for certain is to ask your insurer directly before you file.

A cream plastic bin holding white and manila envelopes sits on a weathered wooden table on a porch with a stone column and white railing, with green shrubs and a dark parked car blurred in the background.

Your insurer's own rules about no-fault claims

Every insurer decides for itself how to treat a comprehensive claim at renewal. Some hold the line and won't raise your rate for a single deer strike. Others count every claim, fault or not, when they calculate your renewal.

This is worth asking about even if you've never filed a claim before. Call your insurer or agent and ask directly whether a comprehensive claim affects your rate, and whether that changes if you file a second one within a certain stretch of time.

If the answer isn't one you like, that's useful to know before you decide whether to file at all. For minor damage, some drivers choose to pay out of pocket rather than risk a rate increase they can't predict.

A person in a dark hooded raincoat walks between rows of parked cars on a wet parking lot under an overcast sky, with a two-story light-colored building and bare trees in the background.

How much damage the deer did, and whether you carry comprehensive coverage at all

If you don't carry comprehensive coverage, hitting a deer isn't covered by insurance at all, and there's nothing to file. This matters most for older cars, where some drivers drop comprehensive because the car isn't worth much anymore.

If you do carry it, the size of the claim matters. A cracked headlight and a totaled car are both comprehensive claims, but insurers who do factor in claims history may weigh a large payout differently than a small one.

Check your policy declarations page to confirm you have comprehensive coverage and what your deductible is. If the repair cost is close to your deductible, filing a claim may not be worth whatever effect it has on your rate.

Questions people ask about this

Does hitting a deer count as an at-fault accident?

No. There's no other driver involved, so there's no fault to assign. It's filed under comprehensive coverage, which exists specifically for events like this, animal strikes, falling branches, and similar damage that isn't a collision with another vehicle.

Will my insurer drop me for hitting a deer?

A single comprehensive claim is unlikely to lead to nonrenewal on its own. Insurers are generally more concerned with at-fault accidents and repeated claims. If you're worried about this, ask your insurer what their policy is on nonrenewal after a comprehensive claim.

Should I file a police report after hitting a deer?

Check your state's rules, since some require a report when damage is above a certain point or when the animal is killed. Even where it isn't required, a report can support your claim if your insurer asks for documentation.

Does swerving to avoid a deer and hitting something else change anything?

Yes, this is usually treated differently. If you swerve and hit a tree, guardrail, or another car, that may be filed as a collision claim instead of comprehensive, and collision claims are more likely to affect your rate. Ask your insurer how they'd classify it before you file.

Is comprehensive coverage required to file a deer-related claim?

Yes. Without comprehensive coverage on your policy, there's no coverage for animal strikes, and you'd pay for repairs yourself. Liability-only policies don't include this protection.

If you're not sure how your current insurer handles claims like this, it's worth seeing what else is out there.

A dark gray sedan parked along a leaf-strewn curb while an older man in a brown jacket walks away down the sidewalk under yellowing trees.

Pull out your policy declarations page and check two things: whether you carry comprehensive coverage and what your deductible is. Then call your insurer or agent and ask plainly whether a comprehensive claim for an animal strike affects your renewal rate. Get that answer before you file anything, not after. If the damage is minor and close to your deductible, weigh paying for it yourself against filing. And if you're already unsure about your current rate or coverage, this is a reasonable time to compare what other insurers would charge for the same coverage.

More articles