
Will My Insurance Go Up if I File a Claim for Hitting a Deer
A deer strike is almost always a comprehensive claim, and comprehensive claims affect your rate differently than an at-fault accident does.
Free to compare
It depends on how your insurer treats comprehensive claims
Hitting a deer is typically covered under your comprehensive coverage, not collision, because you didn't cause the accident by driving choices. Comprehensive claims are rated differently than at-fault claims, and many insurers don't raise your premium for a single one.
That said, it isn't guaranteed across the board. Some insurers factor in any claim, comprehensive or not, when they set your renewal price, and a second animal-strike claim in a short span can read differently than a first one. Check your policy or ask your agent how your insurer specifically handles comprehensive claims at renewal.

Your insurer's own rules matter most
Every insurer sets its own guidelines for how claims affect pricing, and there's no single rule that applies to all of them. Some explicitly exclude comprehensive claims, including animal strikes, from any rate increase. Others look at your total claims history over a period of years without separating out what kind of claim it was.
The only way to know for certain is to ask your insurer directly, before you file, how a deer-strike claim would be handled on your policy. If you're close to a renewal date, ask whether the claim would be reflected by the time your new rate is set.
If you're shopping for coverage and this matters to you, it's worth asking a prospective insurer the same question. Some companies make a point of not surcharging for comprehensive claims, and that policy is usually something they'll state plainly if you ask.

Whether filing is worth it at all
Even if a deer-strike claim won't raise your premium, that doesn't mean filing is automatically the right move. If the damage is minor and close to your deductible, you may end up paying nearly the same amount either way, just spread differently between you and your insurer.
It's worth getting a repair estimate before you decide. Compare that number to your deductible and to what you know about how your insurer treats comprehensive claims. If the estimate is well above your deductible, filing usually makes sense regardless of any small effect on future pricing.
Keep documentation either way. A police report or photos of the damage can matter later, especially if the deer strike caused mechanical problems that don't show up until weeks afterward.
Questions people ask about this
Does hitting a deer count as an at-fault accident?
No, hitting a deer is generally not treated as an at-fault accident because there was no other driver and no way to avoid the animal through different driving behavior. It's filed under comprehensive coverage instead of collision or liability. That distinction is usually what keeps it from affecting your rate the way a collision would.
Do I need a police report for a deer accident claim?
Check with your insurer, because requirements vary by company and sometimes by state. Some insurers want a report any time there's vehicle damage, especially if you're also filing with your own comprehensive coverage. Even when it's not required, a report can help if a dispute comes up later about what happened.
Will my insurance drop collision coverage after an animal strike?
No, a single comprehensive claim for hitting a deer shouldn't affect your eligibility for collision coverage. Insurers typically only reconsider your coverage options after a pattern of claims or a specific type of serious violation. If you're concerned, ask your insurer directly what would trigger a review of your policy.
Should I pay out of pocket instead of filing a claim for deer damage?
That depends on how the repair cost compares to your deductible and what you know about your insurer's claims history policy. If the damage is close to or below your deductible, paying out of pocket may cost about the same and avoids adding a claim to your record. If the damage is significant, filing usually makes more financial sense even if there's some chance it affects your renewal price.
Does comprehensive coverage have its own deductible for deer claims?
Yes, comprehensive coverage usually carries its own deductible, separate from your collision deductible, and you can often set them at different amounts. Check your policy declarations page to see what your comprehensive deductible is. If you don't have comprehensive coverage at all, a deer strike wouldn't be covered by your policy.
If you want to know how a deer-strike claim would actually affect your rate, compare quotes from insurers and ask each one directly.

Get a repair estimate before you file anything, so you know how it compares to your deductible. Call your current insurer and ask specifically how they handle comprehensive claims at renewal, including whether a deer strike would be treated any differently from other comprehensive claims. If you're not satisfied with the answer, or if you're already planning to shop around, ask the same question of a few other insurers while you compare quotes. Keep any photos, repair estimates, or police report from the incident in case you need them later. Decide whether to file based on the actual repair cost against your deductible, not just on what you assume about your rate.


