A white two-car garage door on a suburban home with beige vinyl siding, stone veneer accents, and a black wall lantern.

How Do Insurance Adjusters Decide on a Settlement

An adjuster settles a claim by pricing the damage, assigning fault, and checking what your policy actually covers.

Compare my rates

Free to compare

The settlement comes from fault, damage, and your coverage limits together

An adjuster starts by figuring out who was at fault, because that decides whose insurance pays and how much. Then they price the claim: repair estimates for the car, medical bills and lost wages if anyone was hurt, and any other documented loss. The number they offer is what the evidence supports, capped by whatever limits apply on the policy paying the claim.

For a driver your age, the process is the same as for anyone else. Your age doesn't change how a claim is adjusted. What changes the outcome is how complete your documentation is and whether the adjuster's version of fault matches yours.

A person in a green top and cream cardigan stands at a granite kitchen counter holding a black car key fob in one hand and folded white papers in the other, with a white mug and a bowl of green apples nearby.

Fault decides whose policy pays and how far your own claim can go

Every claim starts with an assessment of fault, and the adjuster forms their own opinion based on the police report, photos, witness statements, and sometimes a reconstruction of how the crash happened. If you're found partly at fault, your settlement can be reduced to reflect that, and in some states a shared-fault finding changes what you can recover at all.

If you disagree with how fault was assigned, say so and ask what the adjuster based it on. You can submit your own photos, repair estimates, or a written account if one wasn't taken at the scene. The earlier you do this, the more it can shape the file before a number is offered.

Fault rules differ by state, so what a shared-fault finding does to your settlement depends on where you live. Ask the adjuster directly how your state handles it, or check with your own insurer before you accept anything.

A person in a dark hooded coat walks between rows of parked white cars on a wet parking lot in front of a low industrial building.

What most people get wrong: the first offer is a starting point, not a verdict

Many drivers treat the first number an adjuster gives as final, when it's really based on whatever documentation exists at that point. If your medical treatment isn't finished, or a repair shop hasn't given a full estimate yet, the offer reflects an incomplete picture. Accepting too early can mean settling for less than the claim is actually worth.

An adjuster also weighs how strong your evidence is, not just what happened. A claim backed by a clear police report, dated photos, and itemized bills moves differently than one supported by a verbal account alone. Keep copies of everything you send and everything you're told, since adjusters work from the file, not from memory.

You're allowed to ask for an explanation of how a number was reached and to push back with more documentation. You're not required to accept the first offer, and nothing obligates you to respond before you've reviewed it carefully.

Questions people ask about this

How long does an insurance adjuster have to settle a claim?

This is set by state law and varies, so there's no single timeline that applies everywhere. Some states require insurers to acknowledge, investigate, and pay claims within set windows. Ask your insurer or the adjuster directly what the deadline is in your state, and get it in writing if you can.

Can I negotiate with an insurance adjuster?

Yes, the first offer is not final and you can respond with more evidence or a counter. Bring repair estimates, medical records, or anything that shows the first number didn't account for the full loss. A written explanation of why you disagree, backed by documents, carries more weight than a phone call alone.

What happens if I disagree with the adjuster's fault determination?

You can dispute it by providing your own evidence, such as photos, witness contact information, or a different account of events. If the disagreement doesn't resolve, some states offer an appeals process through the department of insurance, and you may also have the option to involve an attorney. What's available depends on your state, so ask the adjuster or check with your state insurance department.

Do I need a lawyer to deal with an insurance adjuster?

Not always, and many straightforward claims get resolved without one. It becomes more worth considering when there's a serious injury, a dispute over fault that isn't resolving, or a settlement offer that seems far below your documented losses. A lawyer can also explain deadlines and rules specific to your state that an adjuster isn't required to walk you through.

Why is the adjuster asking for my medical records?

They need them to verify that the treatment relates to the crash and to price the claim accurately. Without records, there's no documentation connecting your injury to the accident, which makes it harder to include in the settlement. You can ask exactly what records are needed rather than handing over your entire file.

Before you deal with an adjuster on your own, it helps to know what your own coverage actually protects.

A person in a plaid shirt pulls the dipstick from the engine of a silver car with the hood raised, in a parking lot in front of a store.

Pull together everything tied to the claim this week: the police report, repair estimates, medical bills, and any photos you took. Write down a plain account of what happened while it's still fresh, even if you already gave a statement. If the adjuster has made an offer, ask them in writing to explain how they reached it before you respond. Call your own insurer if anything about the process feels unclear, since they can explain what your policy requires of you separately from the other driver's insurer. Keep copies of every document and every email, because the adjuster's file and your file should match.

More articles