A dark gray sedan parked alone in a rain-wet parking lot surrounded by green trees under a cloudy sky.

Working With Insurance Adjusters

Stick to facts, get estimates in writing, and ask your own insurer before you accept anything the other side offers.

Compare my rates

Free to compare

Be accurate, be brief, and keep a written record

An adjuster's job is to settle the claim for as little as the policy and the facts allow. That's true whether they work for your insurer or the other driver's. Nothing wrong with that, but it means the burden is on you to describe what happened clearly and to get any damage estimate checked rather than accepting the first number.

Answer what's asked and don't guess or speculate about fault, injuries, or cost. If you don't know, say you don't know. Ask for everything in writing, including the estimate and any offer, so there's a record if you need to dispute it later.

A white plastic bin filled with envelopes sits on a wooden bench on a covered porch, with a dark sedan parked in the driveway and potted shrubs nearby.

Whether it's your insurer's adjuster or the other driver's

Your own insurer's adjuster still works for the company, but your policy gives you some standing. You can ask them to explain how they reached a number, and you can push back if a repair estimate looks low. Ask what the estimate covers and whether it includes parts and labor at a shop you'd actually use.

An adjuster for the other driver's insurer has no obligation to you at all. Anything you tell them can be used to reduce what they pay. It's reasonable to give them the basic facts of the accident and decline to go further, especially on anything about injuries, until you've talked to your own insurer or a lawyer.

Either way, get a second repair estimate from a shop of your own choosing if the first number seems low. You're not required to accept the adjuster's shop or their figure.

A clear plastic bin filled with envelopes and papers sits on a gray bench on a covered porch with stone-clad column, a potted shrub nearby, and a white pickup truck parked in a driveway in the blurred background.

What you say and sign before everything is settled

Recorded statements are optional in most situations, and you can ask what the statement will be used for before agreeing to give one. If a settlement offer comes with a release to sign, read what it releases before you sign it. Some releases close out the whole claim, including costs that show up later.

Keep your own notes. Write down who you spoke with, when, and what was said, right after the call while you remember it. If repairs turn out to cost more than the estimate, that record is what supports asking for more.

If the claim involves an injury or a dispute over fault, it's worth asking your own insurer what your policy covers before you agree to anything with the other side.

Questions people ask about this

Do I have to give a recorded statement to an adjuster?

Usually not right away, and it's reasonable to ask what it's for first. Your own policy may require some cooperation, but you can ask your insurer directly what that requires before giving a statement to anyone, including your own company's adjuster.

Can I negotiate a repair estimate with an adjuster?

Yes. Getting a second estimate from a shop you trust is the usual way to do it. If the two estimates differ, ask the adjuster to explain the gap, and ask your own insurer what the policy says about choice of repair shop.

What happens if I disagree with the adjuster's damage estimate?

You can ask for a reinspection or bring in a second estimate. If that doesn't resolve it, ask your insurer what your policy's dispute process looks like, since it varies by company and by state.

Should I accept the first settlement offer from an adjuster?

Not until you know the full cost of repairs and any other losses. Offers made early in a claim are sometimes lower than what the damage ends up costing, and signing a release can end your ability to ask for more later.

Does talking to the other driver's adjuster affect my own claim?

It can, since anything you say to them becomes part of their file. It's reasonable to give basic facts and refer anything about fault or injury back to your own insurer first.

See how your current coverage compares before your next renewal comes up.

A white cooler holding papers sits on a weathered wooden bench beside a light-colored sided house, with a blurred silver pickup truck parked in a driveway in the background.

Pull your policy and find the claims contact number before you need it, not after. If you're already dealing with a claim, write down the date, time, and name of everyone you've spoken with so far, including adjusters from both sides. Get a second repair estimate if the first number seems low, and ask your own insurer to explain anything in writing you don't understand. Hold off on signing a release until you know the full cost of repairs or any injury treatment. If the other driver's insurer asks for a recorded statement, ask your own insurer whether you're required to give one.

More articles