Close-up of a beige sectional garage door in a stucco-clad residential wall, with green trees and a blue sky visible in the background.

Should I Call the Police After a Minor Accident

Call the police if anyone is hurt, the damage looks more than minor, or your state requires a report, and when in doubt, call anyway.

Compare my rates

Free to compare

Call if there's any doubt at all

If someone might be hurt, if the other driver won't exchange information, or if you can't agree on what happened, call the police. A report from the scene settles questions that come up later, and it protects you if the other driver's story changes once everyone's gone home.

Many states also require a report once damage passes a certain level, even if nobody's hurt. You won't always know that number standing on the shoulder of the road, so the safer move is to call and let the dispatcher tell you whether an officer needs to come out.

A black plastic bin filled with white and manila envelopes sits on a weathered wooden table on a covered porch, with a gray sedan parked on a driveway in the blurred background.

Your state sets the reporting rule

Every state has its own threshold for when a crash has to be reported, and some require it regardless of how small the damage looks. You can find your state's rule through its DMV or department of motor vehicles website, and it's worth knowing before you're standing at the scene trying to decide.

If you're not sure whether this crash meets that threshold, call and ask. A dispatcher can tell you whether an officer will come out or whether you should exchange information and file a report yourselves later.

Even in states that don't require a report for minor damage, you're allowed to ask for one. If the other driver is pushing to settle things without involving police, that's often a reason to call, not a reason to skip it.

A person in a plaid shirt reaches into an open engine bay to pull a yellow-handled dipstick, with a store front and parking lot blurred in the background.

What people get wrong about 'minor'

Damage that looks minor from the outside doesn't always stay that way. Soft tissue injuries and whiplash can take a day or two to show up, and a bumper that looks fine can hide frame damage that costs far more to fix than it appears.

A lot of drivers also assume that if both people agree to handle it privately, there's nothing more to do. But without a police report, you're relying entirely on the other driver's memory and honesty if they change their account later, or if their insurer disputes what happened.

The other common mistake is assuming the police won't bother coming for something small. Many departments will still send an officer or direct you to file a report online, especially if you ask. It costs you a phone call to find out.

Questions people ask about this

Do I have to report a car accident to my insurance if no police report was made?

Yes, most insurers expect you to report any accident, with or without a police report. Check your policy or ask your agent what counts as timely notice, since waiting too long can complicate a claim.

What happens if you don't call the police after a car accident?

Without a report, you have only your own account and whatever photos or witness information you gathered at the scene. If the other driver later disputes what happened or an injury shows up afterward, you may have less to back up your version of events.

Can I still file an insurance claim without a police report?

In many cases yes, but it depends on your insurer and your state's rules. Ask your insurer directly what they need from you if there's no report, and keep any photos, notes, or contact information you collected at the scene.

Should I exchange insurance information even for a small fender bender?

Yes, always exchange names, contact details, and insurance information regardless of how small the damage looks. This is true even if you both agree not to file a claim, since you may need it later if something changes.

Will calling the police after a minor accident raise my insurance rates?

A police report itself doesn't raise your rate. What affects your rate is whether a claim gets filed and who's found at fault, which your insurer determines separately from whether police came to the scene.

See how this kind of accident could affect what you pay before you renew.

A single-story building with light horizontal siding and an attached steel-framed carport shelters a dark gray sedan, with rain falling on a wet concrete lot under an overcast sky.

Before you're ever in this situation, look up your state's accident reporting threshold through your state DMV's website so you know the rule ahead of time. Keep a pen and paper or your phone handy in the car to jot down the other driver's name, license plate, and insurance information. If you're in a minor accident, take photos of both vehicles and the surrounding scene before anyone leaves. Call your insurer the same day, even if you're not sure you'll file a claim, and ask what they need from you given there's no police report. If you're ever unsure whether to call the police at the scene, call anyway and let the dispatcher help you decide.

More articles