A dark metal mailbox on a post in front of a white ranch-style house at sunset.

What to Do If an Adjuster Lowballs Your Claim

A low offer isn't final. You can dispute it with your own documentation, and most insurers have a process for exactly that.

Compare my rates

Free to compare

Ask for the adjuster's reasoning in writing, then challenge it with your own evidence

Start by asking the adjuster to explain, in writing, how they arrived at the number. This usually comes from an estimate, a comparable vehicle value, or a repair quote, and you have a right to see it. Once you know what the offer is based on, you can challenge the specific part that's wrong rather than arguing with the total.

Most of the time a low offer comes from one of a few places. The damage estimate missed something a mechanic would catch. The comparable vehicles used to value your car were in worse shape or had higher mileage. Or the adjuster is going on photos alone and hasn't seen the car in person. Any of these can be corrected if you bring your own documentation.

View from inside a car of an older person's arm in a knit sweater resting on the open passenger window sill, with a side mirror, tree-lined street, houses and a parked white car ahead.

Whether you're negotiating a repair estimate or a total loss value

These two situations call for different evidence. If the dispute is over repair costs, get a second estimate from a body shop you trust, ideally one that doesn't work directly with insurers on volume referrals. Shops that see insurance company estimates every day often know exactly what gets left off and can list it for you in writing.

If the dispute is over your car's total loss value, the adjuster is working from a database of comparable sales. Pull your own comparables, cars of the same year, trim, mileage, and condition, actually listed for sale in your area. Insurers have to respond to specific, documented comparables even when they won't budge on a general complaint that the number feels low.

In either case, keep everything in writing. A phone call where someone agrees to reconsider means nothing later if there's no record of it.

A gray plastic bin filled with white and manila envelopes sits on a gray wooden porch bench beside a stone-veneer wall, with a pickup truck parked in a driveway in the background.

What most people get wrong about pushing back

The common mistake is arguing that the offer is unfair without giving the adjuster anything new to act on. Adjusters aren't required to raise an offer just because you're unhappy with it. They can revise it when you give them something specific their original number didn't account for.

Another mistake is accepting the first offer because the process feels slow or confrontational. You're not required to accept the initial number, and signing a release typically closes out your ability to ask for more later. Read anything you're asked to sign carefully, and don't sign until you're satisfied with the number.

If you and the adjuster genuinely can't agree after you've presented your evidence, ask what your insurer's internal appeal process looks like, or whether your policy includes an appraisal clause. Many policies have one, and it lays out a specific way to resolve a value dispute when both sides have made their case and still don't agree.

Questions people ask about this

Can I hire my own adjuster to dispute the claim?

Yes, this is usually called a public adjuster, and they work for you rather than the insurance company. They typically take a cut of any increase they win, so it's worth asking upfront what that cut is and whether it's worth it for the size of your claim.

Should I get my own repair estimate before talking to the adjuster?

Yes, this is one of the most useful things you can do before any negotiation starts. A shop's written estimate gives you something concrete to compare against the adjuster's number, rather than just a general feeling that it's too low.

What is an appraisal clause in my policy?

It's a provision, included in many policies, that lays out a formal process for resolving a disagreement over your car's value. Each side picks an appraiser, and if those two can't agree, a third appraiser settles it. Check your own policy to see if this clause is included and how it works.

Does filing a complaint with the state insurance department help?

It can, particularly if you believe the adjuster is acting in bad faith rather than just offering a number you disagree with. The state department can't force a specific settlement amount, but a pattern of complaints does get attention, and filing one creates an official record of your dispute.

Will disputing the offer delay my payment?

It can take longer than accepting the first number, since gathering evidence and waiting for a response takes time. Ask the adjuster for a realistic timeline once you've submitted your documentation so you know what to expect.

If this claim has you rethinking your coverage, it's worth seeing what other insurers would offer you.

A wet parking lot with a row of parked cars and one person in dark clothing walking between them, in front of a low tan brick building under an overcast sky.

Ask the adjuster in writing for the specific basis of their offer, whether that's a repair estimate or a list of comparable vehicles. Get your own estimate from a body shop or your own list of comparable vehicles for sale in your area, whichever applies to your claim. Put your counter-offer in writing and reference the specific gaps between their number and yours. Check your policy for an appraisal clause before you assume you're stuck negotiating directly with the adjuster. Don't sign any release until the number reflects what your own evidence supports.

More articles