Close-up of a beige sectional garage door in a stucco-clad residential wall, with green trees and a blue sky visible in the background.

Do I Lose No Claims if Not My Fault

If your insurer can confirm the accident wasn't your fault, your no claims standing is usually protected, but you have to give them the chance to make that finding.

Compare my rates

Free to compare

No, not if fault is established

Your no claims record is tied to fault, not to whether a claim was filed. If your insurer determines the other driver caused the accident, your discount or claims-free status should stay intact, even though a claim went through.

The catch is that someone has to make that determination, and it isn't automatic. Your insurer needs a police report, a statement from the other driver's insurer, witness accounts, or something else that shows clearly who was at fault. Until that happens, the claim can sit on your record as open or undetermined, and some insurers will treat it as a claim either way until it's resolved.

A gray sedan parked inside a garage with an open overhead door, a tennis ball hanging from the ceiling on a string, dark storage cabinets with bins, a tool chest, and a white interior door.

Whether fault gets confirmed in writing

This is the part that decides everything else. If the other driver admits fault, or their insurer accepts liability, your insurer usually has what it needs to clear you. Ask your claims adjuster directly whether fault has been assigned yet, and ask what they're waiting on.

If the other driver disputes it, or there's no police report, this can take longer. Some states use a comparative fault system, where blame can be split between both drivers rather than assigned entirely to one. If you're found partly at fault, your no claims record may be affected even though the accident wasn't entirely your doing.

Keep anything you have from the scene. Photos, the other driver's information, witness names, a copy of the police report if one was filed. If the determination is contested later, this is what your insurer will ask for.

If your insurer rules against you and you believe the other driver was at fault, ask what the appeal or dispute process looks like. Some insurers will reconsider if new evidence comes in.

A dark gray car waits beside a drive-through window with a pneumatic tube canister unit mounted on a stucco and stone wall under an overcast sky.

How your insurer defines a protected no claims record

Not every insurer handles this the same way. Some offer what's called a protected no claims discount, where a certain number of at-fault claims won't affect your status at all, separate from the not-your-fault question entirely. Others only protect your record for not-at-fault accidents and nothing else.

Ask your insurer directly how they classify this accident on your record, not just whether your rate will change at renewal. There's a difference between a claim marked not-at-fault and a claim that's simply absent from your pricing calculation. The first can still show up in your claims history even if it doesn't raise your premium.

This matters if you switch insurers later. A new insurer will look at your claims history, and a not-at-fault accident that's clearly marked as such usually won't count against you. But if the record is ambiguous or the fault determination was never finalized, a new insurer may price it more cautiously than your current one would.

If you're shopping for a new policy soon, ask any insurer you're considering how they treat not-at-fault claims specifically, since the answer isn't the same everywhere.

Questions people ask about this

Will my rate still go up after a not at fault accident?

It can, even if your no claims status itself isn't affected. Some insurers factor in the accident as a general risk indicator regardless of fault, especially if you've had other claims recently. Ask your insurer directly whether this specific accident is affecting your premium and why.

How long does a not at fault determination take?

It depends on how quickly the other driver's insurer responds and whether there's a police report or clear witness evidence. Straightforward cases can resolve in a matter of weeks. Disputed ones can take much longer. Ask your adjuster for a timeline and check in if you haven't heard anything.

What happens if the other driver's insurer disputes fault?

Both insurers may investigate separately and could reach different conclusions, which can delay things. If the dispute isn't resolved, some states have arbitration processes between insurers that don't require you to do anything further. Ask your insurer whether that applies in your case.

Does a not at fault accident still show up on my driving record?

It can appear in your claims history with your insurer even if it doesn't affect your license or your discount. Whether it shows up with the state DMV depends on the state and whether a report was filed. Check with your state's DMV for how they handle it.

Can I remove a not at fault accident from my record once it's confirmed?

Some insurers will update your file once fault is clearly assigned, so the accident shows as not-at-fault rather than open or pending. Ask your insurer whether this happens automatically or whether you need to request it once the determination comes through.

If fault hasn't worked out the way it should, see what other insurers would offer instead.

Close-up of a black perforated leather car seat with headrest beside a B-pillar with an adjustable seat belt height anchor, with blurred green foliage visible through the window.

Call your insurer and ask directly how this accident is currently classified on your file, not just whether your premium changed. Ask what evidence they're waiting on to confirm fault, and give them anything you have from the scene, including photos, the other driver's details, and a police report if one exists. If your renewal is coming up before the determination is final, ask whether that timing affects your rate. Once fault is confirmed, ask for written confirmation that the claim is marked not-at-fault, since this is what a new insurer will want to see if you shop around later.

More articles